When you need a secure place for cash, checks, and small valuables at a checkout station, the first question is simple: do you want a compact tray you can carry between counters, or a fixed drawer that lives under the register? These two options sit in the same price zone, but they take different paths to the same job.
The Office Depot Locking Cash Tray is a brand-new, sealed unit with a locking cover and organized compartments for bills and coins. The Toast POS TC200/TC200W Cash Drawer is a metal drawer with a removable coin compartment and a media slot, available in open-box condition. The choice comes down to how you move and store cash in your cash handling and mailroom routine.
Quick verdict
Choose the Office Depot Locking Cash Tray if you want a brand-new, sealed unit and expect to move cash around. Choose the Toast POS TC200/TC200W Cash Drawer if you prefer a drawer-style unit and are comfortable with open-box condition. At $62.99 vs $65.00, price barely separates them.
At a glance
| Product | Price | Locking | Build | Coin storage | Condition |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Office Depot Locking Cash Tray | $62.99 | Locking cover | High-impact construction | Organized bill and coin compartments | New, sealed packaging |
| Toast POS TC200/TC200W Cash Drawer | $65.00 | Lockable | Metal | Removable coin compartment | New - open box |
Where the Office Depot Locking Cash Tray wins
The Office Depot tray makes the most sense when cash has to travel. It is sealed in its original packaging, so it arrives as a ready-to-use till for a new setup. The tray-style design fits naturally on a counter and is easy to carry to a back office or mailroom station when you need to balance the drawer. If you have one central cash handling point and never move the float, this advantage matters less.
Where the Toast POS TC200/TC200W Cash Drawer wins
The Toast drawer is the better pick when your cash station has a fixed register spot. It is built around the needs of restaurant, bar, and retail counters, so it feels at home in a busy checkout lane. A drawer of this style also gives you a more solid, register-ready footprint than a portable tray. Open-box condition is the trade-off, but the product itself is still new.
Product notes
Office Depot Locking Cash Tray
The Office Depot Locking Cash Tray comes sealed in its original packaging, which is a comfortable position when you're equipping a new register or mailroom drawer for the first time. Its locking cover is the main reason to pick it: it protects bills and coins during transport and during daily operations, and the high-impact construction is built to withstand repeated handling. The organized compartments for bills and coins make end-of-day counting faster because denominations stay separated. The trade-off is that this is a tray, not a full-size drawer. If your setup needs a fixed drawer that slides into a cash register, the office tray will feel more like a portable strongbox than a permanent till. For a compact, lockable, ready-to-use cash tray, it delivers what it promises.
Toast POS TC200/TC200W Cash Drawer
The Toast POS TC200/TC200W Cash Drawer is one of those service-counter pieces that just fits a restaurant or retail register. The metal body gives it a more permanent, counter-ready feel, and the removable coin compartment is a big convenience: you can grab the whole coin tray, refill it, or count it away from the drawer. The media slot adds a dedicated place for checks, coupons, or other valuables, and the lockable feature works alongside the included key. Its main limitation is the condition: the unit is new but in open-box state, so you're not getting the sealed-package experience of the Office Depot tray. If that matters less than having a metal drawer with modular coin storage, this is the pick.
Final choice
Choose the Office Depot Locking Cash Tray when your cash handling and mailroom setup requires a tray that can travel from a counter to a back office. Choose the Toast POS TC200/TC200W Cash Drawer when you want a fixed drawer at a restaurant, bar, or retail register. Price is nearly identical, so convenience, condition, and fitting the station matter most.
