Choosing between these two HP all-in-one printers means balancing a lower listed price against a faster office machine. The HP Smart Tank Plus 651 comes in at USD 174.99, while the HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301FDW is listed at USD 229.99. That USD 55 spread separates a high-capacity ink tank printer from a color laser model with more office-oriented features.
Quick Verdict
Choose the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 if you want a cartridge-free tank printer with a lower listed price and a long-running ink supply. Choose the HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301FDW if your priority is faster output and a more capable color laser all-in-one.
Price and Feature Comparison
| Spec | HP Smart Tank Plus 651 | HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301FDW |
|---|---|---|
| Listed price | USD 174.99 | USD 229.99 |
| Black print speed | 11 ppm | 25 ppm |
| Connectivity | Wireless, USB 2.0 | Ethernet (RJ-45), USB 2.0, Wireless |
| Key features | Scanner, Fax | Copier, Duplex, Fax, Scanner |
| Condition | New | Open box |
| Supplies in box | 3 years of ink bottles | Toner and power cable not included |
Where Each Product Wins
- HP Smart Tank Plus 651 wins when a long-running ink supply and a lower listed price matter more than raw printing speed.
- HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301FDW wins when your workflow demands faster output and a more complete set of office functions.
Product Notes
HP Smart Tank Plus 651
This model is a strong fit when you want a tank printer that won't need supplies right away. The box includes three years of ink bottles, covering around 8,000 color pages and 6,000 black pages. It also offers wireless and USB 2.0 connections, and its scanning and fax functions make it a complete all-in-one for a home or light office setting. The main trade-off is speed: at 11 ppm in black, it will take longer to push through large print jobs than the laser alternative. For everyday documents, though, the ink supply and lower listed price give it a serious convenience advantage.
HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301FDW
This one makes sense if a color laser fits your workload and you need more than a basic printer. It includes copier and duplex functions, so you can copy documents and print on both sides without extra steps. An Ethernet connection also gives you a stable option for a wired office network. The catch is that this unit is open box and toner cartridges plus a power cable are not included. You will need to source those before you can start printing, which adds to the listed price. If that extra setup does not bother you, the faster color laser output and office-friendly features make it the more capable daily driver.
Final Choice by Use Case
For everyday household printing and a longer stretch before you need to think about ink, the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 is the easier pick. For a faster, more complete color laser that fits a busy office routine, go with the HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301FDW.
