Choosing between all-in-one printers isn't just about the price tag. You also need to think about how much you print, whether you need faxing or automatic document feeding, and whether you prefer traditional cartridges or refillable ink tanks. The four printers here split into two approaches: two HP Smart Tank models use refillable ink systems, while two Canon PIXMA models use conventional ink cartridges. The listed prices span a wide range, with the lowest listed price 90% below the highest.
If your top priority is a low upfront cost, the Canon PIXMA TS3722 is the obvious starting point. If you print regularly and want a large ink supply included with the printer, the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 changes the way you think about per-page cost. And if you need a complete office function set, the HP Smart Tank 7603 is the all-in-one to weigh.
Listed-Price Comparison
| Product | Listed Price | Price Bar |
|---|---|---|
| HP Smart Tank 7603 | USD 349.99 | |
| HP Smart Tank Plus 651 | USD 174.99 | |
| Canon PIXMA MX922 | USD 350.00 | |
| Canon PIXMA TS3722 | USD 35.20 |
Decision Matrix
| If you want... | Look at... |
|---|---|
| The broadest listed function set in a new unit | HP Smart Tank 7603 |
| Refillable ink tanks with a bundled multi-thousand-page ink supply | HP Smart Tank Plus 651 |
| Deep color depth and high-resolution imaging | Canon PIXMA MX922 |
| A compact all-in-one for everyday printing | Canon PIXMA TS3722 |
Product Notes
HP Smart Tank 7603
This HP all-in-one is the only model in the group that includes print, copy, fax, an automatic document feeder, and wireless together. For anyone with multi-page paperwork, the ADF is a clear reason to pick it, since you can feed a stack of originals instead of handling each page manually. It's a Smart Tank model, which means it is designed around refillable ink tanks rather than single-use cartridges. The limitation is the cost: it sits at the upper end of the listed price range, so it makes sense only if you'll actually use the fax and ADF functions. Otherwise, you're paying for office features you may not need.
HP Smart Tank Plus 651
The central reason to look at this HP Smart Tank Plus 651 is the included ink supply: it ships with ink bottles that print 8,000 color and 6,000 black pages. That makes it a strong fit for a busy home where printing costs add up quickly. It's a cartridge-free tank printer with USB 2.0 connectivity. The limitation is the listed black print speed of 11 ppm, which is modest compared to many office printers. For steady home printing it's fine, but if you frequently need fast, long documents, you may find the pace slower than you'd like.
Canon PIXMA MX922
The Canon PIXMA MX922 is listed at the high end of this group, and it's marked as open box even though the title says never used. The reason to consider it is the imaging side: it offers 48-bit color depth and a 2400x4800 DPI scanner, specs that stand out in this group. It also includes copier and scanner functions. The limitation is the open-box condition combined with the highest listed price; you're accepting a unit that may have been opened or returned. If you don't need that level of scan detail, this is harder to justify.
Canon PIXMA TS3722
The Canon PIXMA TS3722 has the lowest listed price in the group, making it a low-cost entry point for a compact home office that prints documents and photos. It handles borderless photos, envelopes, and banners using a hybrid ink system with pigment black and dye-based colors. It prints and scans, and its compact size is a practical fit for small desks. The limitation is the feature list: with printing and scanning as its listed functions, it's a better fit for straightforward work than for multi-page office workflows. It also has a 16-bit color depth, which is lower than the 48-bit color depth on the Canon PIXMA MX922.
Final Recommendation by Use Case
- Lowest upfront cost: The $35.20 Canon PIXMA TS3722 is the pick for a home office that mostly prints documents and photos without needing fax or ADF.
- High-volume home printing: The $174.99 HP Smart Tank Plus 651 is the pick if you want refillable ink tanks and an included ink supply good for 8,000 color and 6,000 black pages.
- Full office feature set: The $349.99 HP Smart Tank 7603 is the pick if you want fax, copy, scan, and an automatic document feeder in a new all-in-one.
- High-resolution scanning: The $350.00 Canon PIXMA MX922 is the pick if you need 48-bit color depth and a 2400x4800 DPI scanner and accept an open-box unit.
